I have a couple friends that work at Honda car dealership (I have 4 Honda's) right next to where I work. They often say that the dealership will gouge Honda when they can with warranty and recall stuff. Is there any chance Phil that your warranty is increasing profit for the dealership? I mean I know you probably wouldn't use them if you thought so and you like them but did both your odd failures come out of the blue or shortly after service? Just seems extremely odd you have those rare failures and a warranty.
I've wondered about that, Slider. But the water pump failure came 4,000 miles after a service and was a small oil-leak that showed up suddenly. That, according to my tech, indicated a seal failure where the pump shaft comes out of the crankcase. The muffler was cracked (and I suppose that could have happened in one of my drops), but since it didn't cost me anything, I didn't worry too much about it.
The dealer sold me the extended warranty, but it came from Honda, and I can't imgaine that they'd be real thrilled about their dealers selling extra 4 years of warranty if it got abused very badly by the mechanics.